Best Cheesesteak in Town

Trenton-style tomato pies in Forest Hills

Order online

Trenton-style tomato pies

Lillo’s brings its New Jersey tomato-pie tradition to Forest Hills.

View the menu

Philly cheesesteaks

Cheesesteaks are one of the house specialties, alongside the pies.

Order online

From New Jersey to Queens

New Jersey tradition meets New York City energy at Lillo’s Tomato Pies.

Our story

Pies, slices, and knots

Three Lillo’s locations

Find Lillo’s in Forest Hills, Hainesport, or Gloucester City.

Find a location

This is a new place in town and I’m honestly glad I stopped by! I had the cheesesteak and my mind is blown at how good it was! We aren’t supposed to get this level of quality in NYC! They are generous with the beef, the bread is fresh and the cheese is a perfect amount. This things is lunch and dinner size! I’ll definitely be back for the Pizza!

Jose L.

Ordered half a cheesesteak with the 2 cheeses and onions. I've had cheesesteaks all over Philly and south Jersey, but never had I tried Lillo's. It blew me away. It was by far the best cheesesteak I've ever had, Forest Hills is so lucky to have them.

Joseph D.

Tried both cheesesteak and the grandma pizza slice, both AMAZING. Bread for cheesesteak so FRESH, cheesesteak perfect and pizza was so delicious and CRISPY! Will be back for sure!

Mar L.

Absolutely delicious cheesesteak! I truly have not had a cheesesteak this good in a while. It was ripping hot with the perfect amount of gooey cheese and soft onions. Could not be happier that this place opened up in Forest Hills. Service left a little to be desired, but with food this good, I didn’t even care.

Camila S.

Cheesesteak is outta control and that tomato slice was so fire. Forest Hills lucked out with Lillo’s! Cant wait to go back and try more!

Gregory L.